A surplus figure is only as good as the paper under it. Every dollar of a real claim traces to a document recorded at the county. Learn to pull and read the right ones and you can tell in minutes whether an “$84,000 surplus” is a payday or a mirage. This guide walks the documents in the order they matter.
1. The notice of sale
The notice of sale (a Notice of Trustee's Sale in power-of-sale states, a notice of sheriff's sale in judicial states) announces the auction. It gives you the sale date, the opening bid, the trustee or attorney running it, and a reference to the deed of trust or judgment being foreclosed. Treat the opening bid here as a floor the lender set — not the real debt. Its main value is pointing you at the instrument that foreclosed.
2. The trustee's or sheriff's deed
After the sale, the winning bidder receives a Trustee's Deed Upon Sale (non-judicial) or a Sheriff's Deed (judicial), and it is recorded. This is the document that fixes the winning bid — the actual price paid. Winning bid on the deed, minus the recorded payoff of the foreclosing loan, is your surplus ceiling. If the deed shows the lender itself took title for the opening bid (a credit bid), there is usually no surplus at all — a critical distinction a bid-minus-bid list cannot see.
3. The foreclosing mortgage or deed of trust
Pull the actual recorded mortgage or deed of trust that foreclosed, plus any recorded modifications. This is the real debt that gets cleared first — the number the opening bid often hides. The original principal, the recording date, and its lien position are all here. Position matters enormously: a first lien that forecloses wipes everything junior; a junior lien that forecloses leaves the senior standing.
4. Assignments and releases — the live-or-dead test
This is where most amateurs go wrong. A lien on record is not necessarily a lien that still bites:
- AAssignment — the loan was sold to another servicer. It does not change the amount, but it tells you who holds it and whether the foreclosing party had standing.
- RRelease / reconveyance / satisfaction — the lien was paid off. A recorded release means that mortgage, judgment, or HOA lien is dead and should not be subtracted from the surplus.
Miss a release and you will undercount the surplus; miss a live junior lien and you will overcount it. Reconciling the stack against its releases is the single highest-leverage read in the whole process.
5. Junior liens, HOA liens, and recorded judgments
Search the owner's name and the parcel for everything else recorded against the property and the person: second mortgages, HELOCs, mechanic's liens, HOA assessment liens, IRS or state tax liens, and money judgments against the former owner. Anything junior to the foreclosing lien and not released is paid out of the surplus before the owner — in recording-date priority order (tax and some statutory liens jump the line). A judgment is the quiet killer: it is a claim against the person, attaches to their surplus, and is invisible to anyone only looking at the sale figures.
Putting it together
Stack them in priority order, strike the released ones, and walk the money down:
That is the job, every time: pull the primaries, test each lien for life, order by priority, and subtract. It is slow, county portals are uneven, and document images are often paywalled or captcha-walled — which is precisely the work SurplusLedger does on every lead, handing you the figure, the ordered lien stack, and copies of the documents so you verify and act instead of starting cold.
Educational information, not legal advice. Lien priority and claim rules vary by state and change — confirm the current statute before acting.